Consistency Key to Higher Engagement on Instagram – What’s Working on Instagram Ep2

Table of Contents

We analyzed every post to Instagram from Tailwind members in the past month and uncovered the five posts with the highest engagement rates.  We discussed these five posts with special guest Avery Oden, a Gold Addy Award Winning social media marketer from Staplegun agency, to discover why audiences were so engaged with them and what lessons other Instagram marketers can learn from them.

The big takeaway was that consistently posting to Instagram increases engagement rate overall.  But we learned so much more besides…

What we learned

  • Consistency is key.  Consistently posting the kind of Instagram content that your audience expects from you generally results in higher engagement rates.  In fact one of our winners claims to have increased her engagement rate substantially by posting to Instagram 2-3 more times per week whilst remaining consistent.
  • But… we should leave room to experiment with new and different types of posts that can deepen our relationship with our customer, like behind the scenes posts.  Ideally this should be creative treatments of the subject, for example by showcasing how something was made.
  • Hashtags are essential, but you really have to get involved in your niche and test out which hashtags work for you.
  • The hashtags with the most posts are not necessarily the best ones as your gram will often get buried quickly in the feed.
  • Posting about trending topics (like Chinese mooncakes) and popular culture (like Starwars) can be powerful when paired with the right hashtags.
  • Activate a passionate audience (like those passionate about the environment, or those who have a deep love for Toronto) for consistently high engagement.  Use the appropriate hashtags (like #ilovetoronto) to further your penetration with that group.
  • Watch the video below for all of the takeaways (49m)


What’s Working on Instagram – Ep2 (October 2016) 


  Activate a passionate audience for consistently high engagement on Instagram. Click to Tweet


Posts from September 2016


9-21-2016, @estynhulbert, 462 followers, post engagement score  77

Estyn Hulbert of Estyn Hulbert Jewlery said:

I made a commitment at the beginning of September to start posting 2-3 times a day instead of 4-5 times a week and it seems like the algorithm is favoring people who post frequently because my engagement immediately went up.


I also discovered that using at least one hashtag in the description of the picture, instead of just in a separate comment, got me more engagement and new subscribers. One post ended up in the top 9 results for #pearls for over 36hrs and got over 800 likes. I went from 274 followers to over 500 in less than a week!




9-10-2016, @mykitchenlove, 4,133 followers, post engagement score  79

Samantha Dawn of My Kitchen Love joined us live and said in the comments:

Hashtags are key for gaining followers, features, and engagement.

Regarding the fact that she posted three different photos of this cake she said:

[The] photos were taken at different times. A close up is a great “sneak peak” to keep followers engaged.  The second photo [this one] was posted at my best time of 7:30/8pm PST.



9-5-2016, @superadrianme, 9,785 followers, post engagement score  82

We managed to reach Adrian of Super Adrian Me via email and he said:

At the end of the day it is all about experimenting and sharing compelling content. Some work, some don’t work. Also there’s just too many components in the equation. Be it timing of post, genre of post, hashtags used, colours etc. But it is all about testing and learning I guess.

And on how and why he composed this image, Adrian said:
The textured back ground is a cardboard background. Mooncakes are a Chinese culture during Mid Autumn Festival.




9-2-2016, @greenpickers, 607 followers, post engagement score  85




9-5-2016, @davidcrighton_art, 619 followers, post engagement score  116

Pam Johnston, business partners with artist David Crighton, joined us live and confirmed that Honest Eds is a Toronto landmark.  She said:

Very sentimental favourite of Toronto-nians and David’s art is well known and loved by everyone. He’s captured the spirit of City and what’s in their hearts!



A big thank you to our highest engagement posters for your work and your insights and to our live audience for the lively discussion.

Related Posts

How to get more Instagram comments

How to get more Instagram likes

How to get more Instagram followers

Instagram contest ideas


Unleash the power of Tailwind for Instagram!

Get more likes with our smart schedule
Easily Regram with our browser extension
Save hours with our intuitive desktop & mobile apps
– Post smarter with profile and post analytics

Signup for Tailwind for Instagram


Watch Tailwind's marketing team discuss high engagement Instagram posts with Gold Addy Award Winning social media marketer Avery Oden


Related Posts

Latest Post

Follow Us

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Find out about great deals on Tailwind plans, new blog posts, and invitation only events. Subscribe to our emails today. 

Share this post with your friends