Tailwind Blog

Skyrocket Falling Instagram Engagement with Stories!

Published by
Kristen Dahlin

If you’ve noticed a significant drop in engagement on your Instagram feed, you’re not alone. From algorithm mysteries to rumors of shadowbanning, it can be difficult to keep up. But one thing is for sure, Instagram is definitely changing the way you (and the broader Instagram audience) see your content on your feed, IGTV, and Instagram Stories!

The tricky part about negotiating these changes is that Instagram, like every other network, is very tight-lipped about how the algorithm works. 

While this is helpful to prevent spammy accounts from “gaming the system”, it can be a real headache for regular users who just want to grow their accounts organically! #HeardThat 🙄

However, don’t get too down about it. There are a ton of tools and tips to help you boost your engagement and chase the reach you’re dreaming of!

Our latest favorite? Instagram Stories!

If you want to use Instagram Stories to grow your engagement and help boost your reach, keep reading. 

Do Instagram Stories Affect the Algorithm?

Many Instagram growth strategies tend to focus on how the Instagram algorithm affects posts in your feed – after all, the feed has been around forever and we are comfortable in the feed! 

That’s why when engagement seems to stall on feed content, Instagram users grow frustrated and feel like nothing works!

If this has been your experience, there might be a fix you haven’t REALLY tried yet – Instagram Stories. And because Instagram Stories do affect the algorithm, especially when it comes to helping more of your followers see your posts on their feed first, you owe it to yourself and your business to give it a try.

Let’s break it down.

After rumors of algorithm changes surfaced last year, Instagram published a statement on Twitter:

This is the clearest messaging we’ve seen from Instagram about how the algorithm (or feed ranking) works. Basically, the algorithm is designed to rank your posts based on the activities of your audience such as:

  • The accounts they engage with the most (and if you’re one of them!)
  • How often they use Instagram
  • How many people they follow
  • How recent your posts are

Instagram’s tagline on Twitter is a good summation of what the algorithm is ultimately supposed to do for users:

In other words, the algorithm is designed to put family, friends, and accounts of interest in users’ feed first. If they rarely interact with your content, chances are it won’t appear very high in their feeds. 

If they can’t see your posts on their feed, they can’t interact with them, meaning your engagement doesn’t change. Ugh!

However, there is a place they might be even more likely to see your content – Instagram Stories!

Why Instagram Users Are More Likely to View Your Stories Before They View Your Feed

Instagram Stories disappear after 24 hours, which means there’s a clear time limit on viewing Story content before it’s gone forever.

While a user can view your feed any time they like, they’re usually aware that they have a limited time window to view content and take advantage of things posted in Stories – like discounts, promotions, products, or just more content from accounts they love!

To avoid major FOMO (fear of missing out), most users gravitate towards story content before scrolling their feeds. It also helps that IG Stories from accounts you follow are displayed right at the top of the Instagram home page (look below to see what we mean!).

All of this works in your favor when you begin regularly postingStories content. You have a chance to nab more Impressions, Reach, Interactions and more, which tells the algorithm that your content is interesting and relevant both in general and to those followers. 

Therefore, your actual posts are more likely to appear in their feed, giving them a chance to engage – and drive your feed ranking even higher!

Speaking of Reach, Impressions, and Interactions, let’s pause here to take a look at the actions that influence the algorithm.

Instagram Story Insights, and What They Mean For Engagement

Instagram Insights sheds some light for you (and the algorithm) about how people are interacting with your content.

Below is a recent Story post from my account. (Note: I don’t often find burritos in my purse. Freebirds Burritos are just really big and hard to finish in one sitting! 😩🌯)

In the bottom left corner, you can see where it tells you how many people have viewed your Story.

 If you tap this icon, a popup screen with your Story Insights will appear!

Any engagements from your viewers – replies, profile visits, follows, etc. send a signal to Instagram that your content is engaging and valuable, and deserves more reach!

How to Increase Instagram Stories Engagement

That’s all very nice, but how do you actually increase engagement on Stories?

We can help. Here are some quick tips to maximize those clicks, Instagram Story views, and profile visits!

1. Use Stickers That Your Followers Can’t Resist

People love to interact with their favorite accounts, and Instagram Stories makes interaction easier than ever! Stickers like Questions, Polls, and Quizzes give your followers a chance to weigh in on your content and even get a response.

Make a habit of including these stickers in your IG Stories so that your followers can build a connection with you – and interact with your content!

For example, Utah-based bridal designer Natalie Wynn asked her followers to help her make a decor decision using Story Polls.

And Amanda Burnett opened the floor for her followers to ask their burning blog questions.

Not only does this boost your engagement and positively affect your feed ranking, but it also gives you a ton more content for your IG Stories with ease.

For example, Amanda posted her answers to those questions, providing even more Stories for her followers to enjoy and learn from!

2.) Use Your Stories to Send Your Followers to Links

Website visits are one of the Insights tracked for IG Stories, and for good reason! If your followers are clicking links in your Stories, it’s signaling to the Instagram algorithm that your content is quality and something that your followers are interested in!

If you have over 10,000 followers, you’ll gain access to the handy Link in Stories tool. That enables your followers to Swipe Up at the bottom of your Story to be taken to a link of your choice.

For example, fashion account @savannah7’s used this Story to announce a restock, and a link to the featured dress.

If you don’t have 10,000 followers, you can include a CTA to the link in your bio. Profile Visits are also recorded in Insights! Just make sure to drop in a @mention tag with your username, or add an arrow pointing to your profile pic so that viewers can click and be taken to your profile immediately without backing out of your story!

3.) Tease Surprises, Discounts, or Must-Have Info At the End of Your Stories

This final tip is a great way to keep your followers watching your Instagram story without clicking to the next or exiting completely! 

Simply make your first Story a teasing glimpse of a new product, event, discount code or freebie. You can then use your next few stories to explain benefits, feature reviews, OR offer more backstory to your followers!

Then, make your last frame the frame with the info your followers are looking for, with a link, a CTA or a special code!

Why is this effective? Each time your followers click next through your Stories rather than navigating away, it sends a positive signal to the feed ranking that your followers like your content and want to see more of it. Therefore, you can clue your followers in that something good is coming, and end with the prize to keep them watching!

Check out how skincare company Biossance does it on their Stories!

Plus, batching multiple Story frames doesn’t have to be hard work! In fact, you can use Tailwind for Instagram to draft your Story images and schedule them using push notifications to catch times when most of your followers are active on Instagram!

Start a Free Trial of Tailwind for Instagram!

Main Takeaways

Instagram Stories are a great driver for engagement, especially when it seems like your likes and comments from your Feed are flagging. To summarize:

  • Positive interactions with your Stories do count in Instagram’s algorithm calculations, meaning ALL of your content has more opportunity for discovery.
  • Followers who interact with your Stories are more likely to see your content higher in their feeds.
  • Use Instagram Story stickers to encourage interaction and engagement.
  • Clicks on Links in Stories or Link in Bio positively affect your feed ranking! Teasing discount codes, surprises or sneak peeks at the end of your Stories can keep followers interacting with your content longer!
  • Scheduling your Stories with Tailwind is a great way to get into the habit of posting regularly – a great way to continue growing engagement.

Start a Free Trial of Tailwind for Instagram!

Have you seen an Instagram Story or two that was irresistibly engaging? Tell us about it in the comments below!

Pin It For Later 📌:

Kristen Dahlin

Kristen Dahlin is the Content Marketing Manager at Tailwind — your new Marketing team, helping you create social media designs, schedule posts, and optimize across Instagram, Facebook, and Pinterest with one easy-to-use social media management tool. Kristen lives in rural Oklahoma with her husband Kyle, daughter Sophie, boxer Lila, and a very temperamental flower garden.

View Comments

  • Great article, Instagram is one of the most beneficial platforms to build engagement with. People LOVE it but it can be difficult to break through people's mindless scrolling, that's why these tips can be so helpful.

    • Hi Leonardo! You are so right - it can be really tough to capture attention and break the rhythm of scrolling, scrolling, scrolling! I'm glad you found the tips in this post helpful. :) Kristen

  • I have not been able to make my captions space correctly using the Tailwind app. Everything is jumbled up, and I am forced to go back to an outside site to fix the spacing, cut and paste it directly into Instagram after I've already posted. What is the fix for this?

    Also, each time I've scheduled something on Tailwind, I get a prompt saying "It's time to post! Click here to post"- and I have a business account with IG. Is this supposed to be automated, or what am I missing?

    I want to use Tailwind, but because of the spacing and automation questions I am not finding it easier. I would love to find answers and be able to use it!

    • Hi Leigh! Thanks for your feedback. When you say jumbled up, what do you mean - that it's not accepting your line breaks and spacing? One common reason for this is that we automatically hit the space bar after concluding a sentence with punctuation or an emoji! If you add a space after the end of the sentence and then hit the return bar to create line spacing, it will read the space and ignore any line breaks you put in. Try removing extra spaces after the ends of your lines and emojis and see if this helps!

      Business accounts are the only accounts at present that Tailwind can Auto Post with, but you will have to set up the Auto Posting feature first! In your Tailwind dashboard, you should see a banner at the top of the screen (in desktop!) to help you set up Auto Posting. If this doesn't work for any reason, try reaching out to our CS team via chat or email for help! Thanks for your comment. :) Kristen

  • ok ok I get it! I need to be more consistent & take advantage of if stories more ... it's time 😉👍 Thanks for clarifying how their algorithm functions. What is the pricing for having Tailwind for both Pinterest + Instagram?

Published by
Kristen Dahlin

Recent Posts

What is Marketing Automation? (+ How it Works)

No matter what you do for your customers, getting the word out about your products…

January 12, 2023

Marketing Automation Strategies to Improve Your Business Workflow

One of the most powerful outreach tools for businesses is marketing automation. This allows businesses…

January 12, 2023

What are the Benefits of Marketing Automation?

For all businesses, especially small to medium-sized ones, marketing takes a toll on your schedule.…

January 5, 2023

15 Jewelry Marketing Ideas and Tools to Skyrocket Your Business

There are many ways to market your jewelry business and stand out from the competition.…

January 5, 2023

How to Market a Clothing Brand in 10 Easy Steps (with Examples!)

The fashion industry is an evolving and high-value market. According to Research and Markets, the…

January 5, 2023

How to Create a Successful Email Newsletter

Learn Newsletter Tips and Best Practices for Your Small Business With so many working from…

January 4, 2023